A World of Words

Reviewing children's books

Is ‘Beautiful Creatures’ another Twilight?

on February 2, 2013

Beautiful Creatures, by Kami Garcia & Margaret Stohl

ISBN: 978-0-316-07128-4, £4.99 at the Kindle store

Beautiful Creatures

Is falling in love the beginning… or the end?

In Ethan Wate’s hometown there lies the darkest of secrets.

There is a girl.

Slowly, she pulled the hood from her head. Green eyes, black hair. Lena Duchannes.

There is a curse.

On the Sixteenth Moon, the Sixteenth Year, the Book will take what it’s been promised. And no one can stop it.

In the end, there is a grave.

Lena and Ethan become bound together by a deep, powerful love. But Lena is cursed and on her sixteenth birthday, her fate will be decided.

Ethan never even saw it coming.

I was made aware of this book when, at the cinema to see Les Miserables, I saw the trailer for the film adaptation. Apart from loving the song, which immediately went on my iPod when I got home (Seven Devils – Florence + the Machine), what I saw caught my attention enough to jot down the name and read the book.

Beautiful Creatures is set in the fictional town of Gatlin, South Carolina. Ethan Wate, from whose perspective the book is written, describes his town’s residents as either “stupid or stuck”, and can’t wait to leave, bored with the banality of his life. Fairly soon into the book, the reader is pulled into his dream, where we meet a girl smelling of lemons and rosemary, in need of help. A girl who, although he hasn’t yet met her, Ethan can’t live without.

The girl is Lena Duchannes (“Duchannes rhymes with rain”), with black hair, green eyes, and mysterious powers that see her surrounded by the pathetic fallacy. It’s often raining when Lena’s upset, and at one point there’s even a tornado. Lena’s a Caster, a broader term for a witch that, within her family, also includes a palimpsest, a siren and an incubus. The main premise of the story is that Lena’s family is cursed, and on the night of their sixteenth birthday each member of that family becomes ‘claimed’ as either a dark or light Caster. Lena keeps a count on her hand of how many days she has left until this night, but until she gets to that point, she’s tormented by a Carrie-esque group of Gatlin-born-and-raised girls, alongside much of the rest of the town.

I read quite a good blog post on this a few days ago, although, sorry, I can’t find it again for love nor money now! They pointed out that Ethan had a fair few feminine qualities (being very observant of Lena’s clothes, for example), but that if the story had been written from Lena’s perspective, it would have been 900 pages of teenage angst. I agree with that! It’s easy to see why she would be feeling so fraught though – it is made clear that she has no control over which way she will turn. If she is claimed as a Dark Caster, the book says, her personality will completely change, and she’ll no longer be able to see the family she has grown up with (apart from Ridley, I guess).

I did enjoy the story – it was fast paced, there was always enough going on to hold my attention, and there was a great twist at the end that I didn’t see coming. I really liked the fact that Lena craved normality, even though it was, ironically, the thing that Ethan hates about his town. As a teenager with medical/weight/my share of social issues, I could really relate to the idea that, despite whatever else she had going on, she just wanted to be able to do what everyone else does, no matter how boring or basic it may seem. That really resonated with me.

More spoilers from this point!

I was also really fascinated with the character of Ridley. She came strutting onto the scene and automatically made my jaw drop, as I think she was supposed to. Even when we’re told she’s a Dark Caster, her struggle with good and bad always seems to be lurking somewhere. I thought it really added grit to the book that she and Lena were best friends all through their childhood – you can really tell that Ridley still wants what’s best for Lena, even if that later translates to her trying to help Sarafine turn Lena towards the dark side. Then, later on, it’s obvious she has feelings for Link, and even the darkness within her can’t squash that. It’s an intriguing conflict!

However, I think this book will only ever be a guilty pleasure, and that’s because of the love thing. Now, I must admit, it’s not as bad as the Twilight film (which sickened me, and put me off reading the books), where Bella and Edward meet and she’s almost straight away “in love” with him. However, it’s still obvious almost from the beginning that by the end of the book, Lena and Ethan will have said those 3 overused, under-meant words – “I love you”. She’s 15, and he’s 16, by the way. The book manages to make it seem like their destiny by making their ancestors romantically linked, but I’m still not sure. I admit this may be because I’m slightly biased; I’ve never been in love, and didn’t actually have a boyfriend as a teenager. Maybe it is really easy to fall in love, I don’t know. To me though, being realistic is important – even in a fantasy book. As a reader, I need to be able to relate to the characters in some way, and it seemed like a cliche to make their feelings so intense, despite the events in the book.

Then, there’s the ending. While I really enjoyed the twist at the end, it was over too quickly. There was so much build up to meeting Sarafine, only for her to die (it seemed like) 10 minutes after she was first introduced. Plus, what happened to Ridley? Technically, Lena didn’t choose a side, so I do want to read further on in the series to see what happened to her – I’ll be really disappointed if she’s just forgotten about. As well as this, I want to know more about the name changes – why are they necessary, and do the new names fit them better somehow?

If you want to read more about Beautiful Creatures, I found some good reviews here and here.

Well, if you’ve made it through my rambling, I’m impressed! I know I haven’t mentioned several important characters (Amma, for one), but I’ve covered most of the things I remember thinking about the book. Overall, I did like it and I’ll be going to see the film, as well as reading more of the series, but I did see some parallels with Twilight. What did you think?


5 responses to “Is ‘Beautiful Creatures’ another Twilight?

  1. […] Is ‘Beautiful Creatures’ another Twilight? Feb […]

  2. Way cool! Some very valid points! I appreciate you penning
    this post and also the rest of the site is extremely good.

  3. beckyday6 says:

    Great review! I skipped the last part with the spoilers because right now I am just over half way through the book, but I have to say within the first few chapters I was thinking ‘this is a reverse version of Twilight’ it’s interesting to see that others have thought the same thing!

    • Kayleigh says:

      Thanks! It’s a good book, but there does seem to be a lot of paranormal romance books for teenagers at the moment!

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Emmy's Mummy

and Harry's too!

She Cooks, She Eats

Simple but delicious recipes from a girl that loves to eat

My Little Book Blog

Book reviews and all things books by Lizzy Baldwin

Book Gossips

We are four cousins hailing from Australia. Love of books runs in our family and we have decided to share our exhilirating gossip sessions with you. Here you can find book reviews from multiple genres, bringing you the best of buzz worthy popular fiction.

Reviewing children's books

Fast day feasts

What to eat on the 5:2 fast diet

Once Upon a Bookcase

Reviewing children's books

Dark Readers

Reviewing children's books

The Cait Files

Reviewing children's books

Rape and PTSD

PTSD from Gang Rape - My Journey

Age is just a page number

Now featuring books for adults!

The Barefoot Gigi

Barefoot Books and Gifts for Children

Red Ted Art's Blog

Bringing Colour & Art to Children's Hearts

Becky's Book Reviews

Reviewing children's books


The training centre for tomorrow’s talent


Reviewing children's books

Children's Literature Book Club

Reviewing children's books

Armadillo Blog

Reviewing children's books

tall tales & short stories

Reviewing children's books

Blog Book Tours

Reviewing children's books

Reviewing children's books

Chicken Spaghetti

Reviewing children's books

The Horn Book

Reviewing children's books


Reviewing children's books

Bookreporter.com Reviews

Reviewing children's books

Teen Librarian

libraries, teens, books, reviews news...

Book Reviews – BookBabblers

Reviewing children's books

Reviewing children's books

Scribble City Central

Reviewing children's books

Wondrous Reads

Reviewing children's books

Books 4 Teens

YA reviews, news & interviews for the young & the young at heart

The Acorn and Thimble

Reviewing children's books

The Mountains of Instead

Reviewing children's books

The Bookette

Reviewing children's books

Seven Miles of Steel Thistles

Reviewing children's books

The History Girls

Reviewing children's books

Did you ever stop to think and forget to start again?

Reviewing and talking about children's literature, graphic novels & bookish things. Shiny.

Writing from the Tub

Reviewing children's books


A critical-whimsical romp through children's literature

Nayu's Reading Corner

Reviewing children's books

the book corner

Reviewing children's books

'The Little Wooden Horse'

Reviewing children's books

Picture Book Shelf

Reviewing children's books

5minutespeace's Blog

A comprehensive blog reviewing children's books with an emphasis on fun and nostalgia.

%d bloggers like this: